Editing Services: A Comprehensive Guide To Finding The Right Editor For Your Book

To achieve their full potential, every writer requires the assistance of an editor who can refine their writing. Hiring a book editor plays a crucial role in determining whether a book becomes a bestseller or a disappointment. Therefore, it is essential to identify the ideal editor for both your manuscript and yourself as the author. This leads us to the central question: How do you locate a suitable book editor? The process of book editing is intricate and extensive, so don’t expect to hire a single individual and consider the job done. Professional book editing typically involves a team of editors, each specializing in different aspects of the manuscript editing services. Unless you stumble upon a superhuman editor who can handle everything, you must decide what type of book editor best suits your needs. Most writers ultimately assemble a team of four book editors: a developmental editor, a copy editor, a line editor, and a proofreader. Alternatively, you may opt for an editorial assessment by a book editor. This assessment provides you with feedback on your book’s overall strengths and weaknesses. Armed with this knowledge, you can choose to address key areas of improvement before enlisting a developmental editor. But let’s stay focused on the main question: How can you find the right book editor for your manuscript? There are five steps to discovering the perfect book editor, and by following them diligently, you can assemble an editorial team capable of refining your book to perfection.

1- Independent Manuscript Review

Consider doing some self-editing on your manuscript. While self-editing cannot substitute for a professional editor, it is a valuable step to take before seeking professional editing services. It’s advisable to refine your manuscript as much as possible before handing it over to hire an editor. This not only improves the quality of your work but also reduces your editing expenses. The fewer errors the editor needs to correct, the less money you’ll spend. Here’s how you can enlist the help of amateur editors:

Friends And Family 

Reach out to individuals in your immediate social circles who have expertise in language or literature. These could be English teachers, avid readers, or fellow writers. Although they may not be as proficient as professional editors, they can still spot some errors for you to address. After several rounds of self-editing, their input can provide you with a fresh perspective. Be open to their suggestions, even if they differ from your own, as it can serve as valuable practice for working with a professional book editor in the future.

Beta Readers 

Beta readers are a group of individuals who review your manuscript before it’s published. They offer feedback on what they like and dislike about your story. While beta readers are crucial for quality control, it’s essential to note that they typically do not engage in technical editing. They can provide reviews and insights into your work but lack the expertise for in-depth editing. As many self-publishing authors operate on tight budgets, it may be tempting to cut corners and rely solely on these basic editing rounds. However, as experts in the field of self-publishing, we always recommend seeking professional book editors. To understand why this is crucial, you should be aware of the comprehensive range of services that professional editors offer, helping you determine the type of editing assistance your book requires and enabling you to find the right editor for your project.

2- Determine Your Editing Requirements

If self-editing and collaborating with beta readers were sufficient substitutes for the services of professional book editors and proofreaders, most self-published authors would opt for this route. So, what motivates writers to engage professional editors for their manuscripts? Regardless of the specific editing tasks they perform, all editors play a vital role in the enhancement of a book. Their primary responsibilities encompass: 

1- Enhancing the overall quality of your book by assessing its content. 

2- Guarantee the absence of mechanical errors, including grammar, spelling, and punctuation mistakes, in your book.

3- Identifying disparities and anomalies in both the language employed and the substance of your book.

Naturally, these responsibilities demand a considerable amount of patience, perseverance, and, above all, specialized knowledge. This is precisely why authors enlist the services of dedicated book editors! Your book represents a significant investment of your time and effort, which can make it challenging to evaluate objectively. While your friends, family, and beta readers can offer valuable insights, they lack the training to identify and rectify errors as effectively as professional editors do. What’s more, editors possess a deep understanding of your target audience due to their industry expertise. This expertise makes them invaluable contributors to the self-publishing journey!

What Is The Role Of A Book Editor? 

Depending on their specific type, book editors are responsible for distinct editing tasks:

Developmental Editor: Analyzes overarching aspects of your book, such as its structure and overall flow, with the aim of enhancing the content’s quality. 

Copy Editor: Focuses on removing factual errors and inconsistencies in your book to improve its readability. 

Line Editor: Conducts a meticulous examination of the manuscript, scrutinizing it line by line while concentrating on aspects like tone and emotion. 

Proofreader: Ensures the elimination of minor errors, such as spelling and punctuation mistakes. 

Once you’ve determined which type of editor you require, you can streamline your search. In traditional publishing, this intricate selection process isn’t necessary. Securing a book deal with a publisher typically absolves you of these editing responsibilities. A publishing editor, employed by your publisher, would oversee all these editing stages. However, as a self-published author, you must handle these tasks independently. Rest assured, you’re not alone! We’re here to assist you with such inquiries, including the one we’re addressing now: where to locate a book editor?

3- Freelance vs. Professional Editing Services

When it comes to finding an editor, you have two distinct choices: author services and freelance editors. Each option has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, so let’s delve into how they operate.

Finding Freelance Editors 

Platforms like Reedsy, ServiceScape, and Freelancer provide extensive databases of editors, offering insights into their experience, skills, and specialized areas. This valuable information assists you in selecting the right editor and building an editing team tailored to your needs. However, the drawback is that sifting through the multitude of options can be a cumbersome process, making it challenging to pinpoint the ideal editor. The quest for how to find a book editor often arises from the difficulty of finding the perfect fit in this vast pool.

Trusting Editing Firms 

Author services employ a diverse array of editors with various skills and areas of expertise. Your task is simply to place an order, and they will assemble an ideal team to work on your manuscript. The ultimate outcome is a polished manuscript, ready for the typesetting stage. Another advantage of partnering with author services is their comprehensive packages. If you opt for their services across a range of self-publishing needs, you can enjoy cost savings through bundled discounts!

4- Consider Recommendations, Reviews, And Samples 

If you opt for an editing service, your primary considerations are reviews and recommendations. You won’t need to fret over the other factors listed here because the service will handle the task of matching you with the ideal book editor for your manuscript editing services. However, if you decide to seek out book editors on a freelancing platform, there are several factors to take into account. We’ve outlined some key considerations to help you navigate the extensive pool of online editors.


If you have friends or acquaintances who are self-published authors, inquire about how they discovered an editor. Research the editors they endorse and corroborate these recommendations by examining online reviews from other individuals. If you lack connections with fellow writers, consider building such relationships. Networking is as essential to a self-published author as quality is to PaperTrue – absolutely indispensable. Who would have thought that before finding a book editor, you’d need to connect with fellow writers? On a more serious note, editors recommended by people you know naturally gain an advantage. Their successful collaborations with writers you’re familiar with offer concrete evidence of their work’s quality.


Online reviews simplify the task of finding an editor considerably. They provide detailed insights into an editor’s working style, giving you a clear picture of what collaboration with them entails. Reviews also serve as your best guide in selecting the right book editing service. For instance, PaperTrue boasts a rating of 4.6/5 on Reviews.io and 4.8/5 on Google Reviews.


This is perhaps the most crucial metric to consider. Editing experience is vital for a book editor to grasp industry standards, trends, and reader expectations. Particularly if you’re embarking on self-publishing for the first time, collaborating with an experienced editor is essential. While any book editor with a decent number of reviews is likely to have substantial work experience, if you’re aiming for top-tier editing, consider someone with a background in editing at a publishing house. Experience comes at a cost, but it’s a price worth paying for a polished final result.

Niche Area 

Even if an editor garners rave reviews, possesses impressive experience, and comes highly recommended by your closest contacts, it won’t matter if they lack knowledge in your specific field. For instance, if you’re writing a book on the intricacies of jellyfish anatomy, having a children’s book editor won’t be suitable. Thus, seek an editor well-versed in your genre and niche to avoid inaccuracies and factual errors in your work.

A Sample Edit 

Prior to committing to a particular editor, be sure to request a sample edit. Most book editors provide a brief sample that showcases their work, along with a corresponding quote. A sample edit serves as a comprehensive indicator of the editor’s capabilities. The precision of their work and the feedback they provide will help you determine if they are the right match for your project.

5- Identify The Cost Of Editing 

Editing services come at a cost, and this expenditure is justified. A book editor not only rectifies errors in your manuscript but also enhances its overall value. Naturally, an editor with an excellent reputation and years of experience will command higher fees for their services. Therefore, when you’re contemplating how to locate a book editor, it’s crucial to allocate a budget for this purpose. We recommend considering collaboration with skilled but relatively less experienced book editors to economize your valuable resources. However, this decision is seldom straightforward. For a more detailed discussion on the cost of book editing and its place within the context of various self-publishing stages, please refer to this article.

Create A Checklist To Find The Perfect Book Editor 


We have compiled a checklist of questions to aid you in finding the perfect book editor. You can employ these questions to streamline your search or formulate your own checklist based on this model!

Similar Posts